My go-to charcoal chimney has always been the Weber Rapidfire Charcoal Chimney - it works better and holds more charcoal than any other chimney...until now.
This year, Char-Broil released the Char-Broil Half-Time Charcoal Starter, with a new, wider design with a lot more holes for airflow. I compared the two head-to-head, and...the results were inconclusive. The Char-Broil was definitely faster - it was ready in 22 minutes, vs 31 minutes for the Weber - but it also holds less charcoal. (The Char-Broil is wider than the Weber, and shorter. The result is the Weber holds about a quart more charcoal.)
After taking these pictures, I realized my test was invalid. I need to re-test, filling both chimneys with the maximum amount of charcoal the Char-Broil can hold in both chimneys. In other words...more news to come.
Weber Rapidfire Charcoal Chimney [Amazon.com]
Char-Broil Half-Time Charcoal Starter [Amazon.com]