Description
A 2 1/2 inch thick bone-in ribeye smoke-roasted slowly over indirect heat on a charcoal grill, then seared over fresh coals and basted with shallot and thyme butter.
Ingredients
- 1 cowboy chop (double cut bone-in ribeye, 2 1/2 inches thick, about 2 pounds)
- 2 teaspoons kosher salt
- 1 teaspoon fresh ground black pepper
- 2 fist-size chunks smoking wood (or 1 oak wine barrel stave)
Butter baste
- 4 tablespoons butter
- 1 small shallot, minced
- Leaves from 1 sprig thyme
Instructions
- Season: Two hours before grilling, season the steak all over with the salt and pepper, and let it rest at room temperature.
- Set up the grill: Set up a charcoal grill for indirect medium-low heat, about 300°F. Light half a chimney of charcoal (about 50 coals), and when they're mostly covered with gray ash, pour them on one side of the grill. Add the smoking wood to the coals.
- Cook on indirect heat: Put the steak on the side away from the coals. Close the lid, with the vents over the steak to pull the smoke across it. Flip every 5 minutes, keeping the lid closed as much as possible, until the thickest part reaches 115°F for medium rare, 30 minutes to 1 hour. (105°F to 110°F for rare, 125°F for medium.)
- Light more coals: After 15 minutes, or when the steak reaches 80°F, light another half chimney of charcoal on a heat-safe surface.
- Melt the butter baste: Put the butter, shallot and thyme in a small grill-safe pot over the coals when the steak goes on. When the butter melts and the shallot sizzles, slide the pot to the cool side to stay warm. (Or melt it on the stove or in the microwave.)
- Sear: Carefully pour the fresh coals onto the coals in the grill. Brush the steak with butter, and move it over the coals. Sear with the lid open, flipping and basting every minute or two, until well crusted and 125°F inside for medium rare, about 5 minutes. (115°F for rare, 135°F for medium.)
- Rest and serve: Move the steak to a platter, and baste it one last time. Let rest for 15 minutes, then slice and serve.
Notes
Equipment: A charcoal grill (I use a Weber kettle), a chimney starter for the second batch of coals, and a probe thermometer and/or an instant read thermometer. A probe thermometer is the way to go; with an instant read, check every time you flip.
Timing varies. My steak sat around 53°F for the first 20 minutes, then climbed quickly. Plan on extra time.
On a gas grill: set one burner to high and leave the rest off, adjusting it to hold 300°F. Use a cup of soaked wood chips in a foil packet over the lit burner instead of chunks. When the steak is ready, turn all the burners to high, and sear over the burner that was lit the whole time. The sear won't be as good as over charcoal.
Flipping every 5 minutes seems like a lot, but it gives very even cooking, as even as my beer cooler sous vide steaks.
Adapted from The Food Lab's Perfect Grilled Ribeye Steaks at Serious Eats.
- Prep Time: 10 minutes
- Season and rest: 2 hours
- Cook Time: 1 hour 5 minutes

