Instant Pot Turkey Legs with Poultry Seasoning

Instant Pot Turkey Legs with Poultry Seasoning. Turkey drumsticks with a taste of Thanksgiving from my pressure cooker.

To be technically correct - the best kind of correct - these are turkey drumsticks. A turkey leg is both the thigh and the drumstick. But…everyone calls the drumstick “turkey legs” in their Google searches. And that’s what they sell at State Fairs and RenFaires. Disneyland has their famous “Jumbo turkey legs.” They’re all drumsticks, but I can’t fight Google searches, state fairs, period accurate cosplayers, and the House of Mouse at the same time. I can’t!

This recipe is similar to my pressure cooker state fair turkey drumsticks (Sigh. Named back when I was pounding the drumstick drum). I’m simplifying with Poultry Seasoning, a blend of spices that just say “Thanksgiving” to me. See the Substitutions section for how to make your own poultry seasoning if you need it. Also, it needed a little color, so I added some paprika for a dash of red. (Poultry mix tastes like Thanksgiving, and looks olive, drab, and boring coming out of the pressure cooker.)

Jump to:

• 🥫Ingredients
• 🥘 Substitutions
• 🛠 Equipment
• 📏Scaling
• 💡Tips and Tricks
• 🔪Recipe
• ☃️ Storage
• 🤝 Related Posts
• 💬 Comments

🥫Ingredients

• Turkey legs (drumsticks)
• Poultry Seasoning
• Fine sea salt
• Paprika
• Brown sugar

See recipe card for quantities.

🥘 Substitutions

Turkey Legs: As I said above, turkey legs are not the entire leg, just the turkey drumstick. If you get turkey thighs, the seasoning will still work, but they need to cook for 30 minutes at high pressure, with a Natural Release, to cook all the way through.

Poultry Seasoning: I like McCormick’s poultry seasoning, because it is thyme and sage forward. Bell’s Seasoning is another classic option, but it has a lot of rosemary, which isn’t to my taste. That said, and any poultry or chicken seasoning will work. (I have a soft spot for Montreal Chicken seasoning, too, when I want chunky looking spices on the legs.)

Make your own poultry seasoning: Here is a simplified, homemade version, if you need it: mix 1 teaspoon dried thyme, 1 teaspoon dried sage, ½ teaspoon dried marjoram, and ½ teaspoon fresh ground black pepper. You can use it as-is, but If you want a powder (like most poultry seasonings), pulse the mix in a spice grinder.

I add the paprika for color and a hint of flavor, but you can skip it if you want. I sprinkle a pinch of paprika and poultry mix on after cooking to brighten up the colors of the legs - they look a little drab straight out of the pressure cooker.

I also add a little brown sugar to my spice rub, because I like to give my turkey a hint of sweet flavor, but it is optional.

I replace the water with chicken or turkey broth if I have it for the cooking liquid, because it gives me an extra rich pot sauce to pass at the table. If all you have is water, that’s fine too, and the pot sauce is OK, just not as full bodied as it is with broth.

🛠 Equipment

A 6-quart pressure cooker

📏Scaling

6 drumsticks will just about fill a 6-quart pressure cooker. They take up a lot of space with the long leg bone, and you don’t want to crowd them. To scale the recipe up or down, use ½ teaspoon of poultry seasoning, ½ teaspoon of fine sea salt, and a pinch of paprika and brown sugar per leg. But, don’t change the water amount - we want 1 cup of water to have enough liquid for the cooker to come up to pressure and cook the legs. We don’t need more and we don’t want less.

You can fit 9 turkey legs in 8-quart pressure cooker. Halving the recipe is fine in a 6-quart cooker or larger, but 3 legs just barely fit in my 3-quart pressure cooker, and if the legs were any longer I wouldn’t have been able to seal the pot. Check the length of the drumsticks before cooking in a smaller pressure cooker.

💡Tips and Tricks

• Cooking turkey legs from frozen: Frozen legs don’t work as well as thawed or fresh legs - the rub doesn’t stick as well to frozen legs. But, if you’re stuck, you can cook frozen turkey legs by adding an extra 10 minutes to the cooking time under pressure - as long as you can separate the legs from each other. If they are frozen together in a big block, they will take forever to cook.
• Cooking rack? I don’t bother with turkey legs, and just plop the bottom layer of legs into the cooking liquid. If you want to use a rack, you can - it doesn’t change the recipe or the timing. But…make sure the legs still fit with the rack, and you can close the lid.
• Broiling the legs: If you want to crisp up the turkey a little, you can take the turkey legs from the pressure cooker, spread them out on a rimmed baking sheet, and broil them until they are golden brown in spots. The timing will depend on the strength of your broiler, and the distance to the legs - keep an eye on them and don’t let them burn.

Print

🔪Recipe

☃️ Storage

Cooked turkey legs will last for a few days in the refrigerator, or for up to 6 months in the freezer. Other than just eating leftover turkey legs, I shred the meat and use it for turkey salad or tacos, or I toss the leg in a pot of beans to give them extra flavor.

🤝 Related Posts

Pressure Cooker State Fair Turkey Drumsticks
Instant Pot Turkey Thighs with Thanksgiving Flavors
Pressure Cooker Pinto Bean and Turkey Drumstick Soup
My other Instant Pot and Pressure Cooker Recipes

Enjoyed this post? Want to help out DadCooksDinner? Subscribe to DadCooksDinner via email and share this post with your friends. Want to contribute directly? Donate to my Tip Jar, or buy something from Amazon.com through the links on this site. Thank you.